What Does a Producer Do? 7 Real Decisions from Our Shoots
What a producer does, stage by stage, shown through 7 real decisions from commercial and brand video shoots.
A producer is the person who makes a film or a commercial possible: they turn an idea, a budget and a deadline into a crew, a schedule and a finished video. The director decides how the film should look and feel. The producer decides how it can actually happen with the money and time available, and keeps it on track until delivery.
Definitions only go so far, so this guide shows the job through seven real decisions from our own shoots in advertising and brand video, plus insights from a senior producer at TBWA and from our video blog.
In bigger productions the job splits: an executive producer secures the money and the client relationship, a line producer controls the budget and logistics day to day, and production coordinators handle the details. In a small studio, one producer often does all of it.
The director owns the creative vision: performance, camera, the look of every frame. A commercial director is simply a director who specializes in ads. Brands pay for that vision: in our video blog episode on why brands pay millions for Hollywood directors, we look at commercials directed by Martin Scorsese, Wes Anderson and Taika Waititi. One example from that episode shows how the roles can mix: Joseph Kosinski, director of Top Gun: Maverick, joined a BMW film as a producer.
The producer’s side of that story is finding the right director for the budget. As Natalia Tkach, a senior producer at TBWA in the US, told us in our interview about her work with Matthew McConaughey: “Our job is to find the right directors who can make the project shine, no matter the budget.” For a low-budget spot with real children, her team hired a small Brooklyn production house that usually made documentaries with kids.
One note on the search term: in business, “commercial director” can also mean a sales and revenue executive. That is a different job. Here we mean the director of commercials.
For a Vivo TV commercial timed to the FIFA World Cup, the cast included professional footballers whose schedules were packed with training, recovery and medical checks. The budget allowed exactly one shoot day of about seven hours. The producer’s job was to get all the players in one place at one time. Next to the main set, a photographer shot the campaign’s key visuals in parallel, so the talent’s time was used twice.
The players could not wear their standard kits, for legal clearance and for the color grade, so the team made custom grey sleeves with each player’s name and the Vivo logo. Read the Vivo TV ad case.
An investor asked us to shoot stock footage of two luxury cars: at least 100 clips in an eight-hour day. We built two shot schedules in advance, a main one and a contingency. Nothing went wrong, but with the backup ready, nobody had to improvise under pressure. The studio was chosen for two practical reasons: overhead lighting that gave clean reflections on the bodywork, and an entrance high enough for a low sports car to drive in without scraping. Result: 120 finished clips, about 15 setups an hour. See the case.
For a 3M medical device commercial, the concept compared a dentist to an architect, so we wanted a high-rise. A studio meant green screen and painted skylines in post. Rented offices looked sterile and cost too much. Our producer found a private resident willing to rent their apartment in a skyscraper, with a warm interior and a skyline view. The location line in the $13,900 budget came to $800. Read the 3M case.
Rimmel London needed three manifesto videos with three creators, and the schedule and budget allowed one location for a day and a half. The production designer, director and cinematographer split an abandoned factory into three zones, each with its own design code. Small fixes added up: rusty barrels repainted matte black, water spread on the concrete floor for reflections, LED fixtures wired to each of 12 pillars. A small buffer in the schedule paid off when the cinematographer spotted morning light on the roof and grabbed a shot that made the final cut. See the Rimmel case.
For three Vivo mini documentaries about real people, we could not get all three heroes free in the same production week. The producer’s solution: two of the films used actors, and we bought full life-story rights from the real people. The stories stayed true, while the faces on screen changed. Read the Vivo documentary case.
Condé Nast asked us to make a Reebok campaign film inside a cover photo shoot: same studio, same day, same talent. During post-production we noticed that each of the three women had a large audience of her own. So from the same footage we cut three extra 15-second Reels, one for each, and the campaign reached their followers too. See the Reebok case.
On six product films for pet food brands, script discussions went in circles by email. One hour in the client’s office, and the scripts moved in a week. We did the same for color grading: all six films on one screen, reviewed second by second. Our rule since then: when two emails on the same question fail to converge, don’t write a third. Call, or meet. Read the case.
The scale changes, but the job does not. In our interview, Natalia Tkach described her first commercial with Matthew McConaughey. He would only stay in one place each night, even with 4 a.m. calls and changing locations, so the production rented a $150,000 yacht to follow the crew along the coast. On another Lincoln spot with McConaughey, an Oscar-winning composer offered a score for $100,000 on one condition: no changes. The team took it and built the edit around the score and McConaughey’s movements.
Most producers start as production assistants or producer’s assistants and learn on set. Natalia Tkach started as an assistant to a senior producer, and her first campaign happened to star Matthew McConaughey. She told us she did not understand half the terms at first and was afraid to ask, and that phase lasted about three months. Watch how decisions get made, keep a list of what went wrong, and ask questions earlier than she did.
What does a producer do in a commercial?
Builds the budget and schedule, hires the director and crew, organizes casting, locations and rights, runs the shoot and delivers the final versions on time.
What is the difference between a producer and a director?
The director is responsible for the creative result. The producer is responsible for making it happen within the budget and timeline.
What does a commercial director do?
In advertising, a commercial director directs ads: casting, performance, camera and the look of the spot. In business, the same title can mean a sales executive.
Do producers work on set?
Yes. On shoot day the producer keeps the schedule, solves problems and makes sure the client sees and approves the key takes.
Most of the decisions above come from commercials. See how our team takes a spot from brief to broadcast on our TV commercial production page.